eHarmony vs. Match.com

Wednesday, May 19, 2010

When I first decided to join an online dating site, I thought eHarmony was exactly what I needed. I wanted a serious relationship. I wanted to be (spoken in soft, alluring voice) “compatible at the deepest levels” with my next boyfriend. Therefore, I became a subscribing member for 6 months.

I’m still looking for a serious relationship. But after a short break from online dating last winter, I switched to Match.com. Why? Well, first, it was a little less expensive. Second, it was something different—and why shouldn’t I try something different? Third, there’s an offer for 6 months free if I don’t find “someone” in my first 6 months. I love free stuff!

Now, I have to point out that in the back of my head, a snarky little voice is saying, “Can someone please define ‘someone’?” To be fair, I just checked; the site defines “someone” with “special.” And there’s that pesky voice again….

Anyways, I should get to my point: here’s a quick breakdown of what I like and dislike about each of these sites. I had created a nice, neat table for this information. Unfortanately, I'm not quite savvy enough to make Blogger cooperate with my tables...


eHarmony.com

Quick summary: A serious online dating site for individuals who are looking for a serious, long-term relationship

Pros
  • Extensive personality test to ensure “accurate” matching
  • Guided communication (including pre-set and sample questions)
  • Consistent, focus product
  • Easy website navigation
Cons
  • Expensive
  • Member search restricted to matches provided based on personality test
  • No instant messaging system


Match.com

Quick summary: A relaxed, semi-structured online dating site for individuals of all kinds and interests

Pros
  • Ability to search all member profiles
  • Instant Messaging system
  • Offer for 6 months free after first 6-month membership (restrictions apply)
Cons
  • Expensive (but less so than eHarmony)
  • No guided communication features
  • Too many, and inconsistent, matching/communication options
  • Not-so-easy website navigation

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Disclaimer

All names and some details have been altered to protect the innocent ;-)